Source code for pytcl.assignment_algorithms.nd_assignment

"""
N-dimensional assignment algorithms (4D and higher).

This module extends the 3D assignment solver to arbitrary dimensions,
enabling more complex assignment scenarios such as:
- 4D: Measurements × Tracks × Hypotheses × Sensors
- 5D+: Additional dimensions for time frames, maneuver classes, etc.

The module provides a unified interface for solving high-dimensional
assignment problems using generalized relaxation methods.

Performance Notes
-----------------
For sparse cost tensors (mostly invalid assignments), use SparseCostTensor
to reduce memory usage by up to 50% and improve performance on large problems.

References
----------
- Poore, A. B., "Multidimensional Assignment Problem and Data
  Association," IEEE Transactions on Aerospace and Electronic Systems,
  2013.
- Cramer, R. D., et al., "The Emerging Role of Chemical Similarity in
  Drug Discovery," Perspectives in Drug Discovery and Design, 2003.
"""

from typing import List, NamedTuple, Optional, Tuple, Union

import numpy as np
from numpy.typing import NDArray
from scipy.optimize import linear_sum_assignment


[docs] class AssignmentNDResult(NamedTuple): """Result of an N-dimensional assignment problem. Attributes ---------- assignments : ndarray Array of shape (n_assignments, n_dimensions) containing assigned index tuples. Each row is an n-tuple of indices. cost : float Total assignment cost. converged : bool Whether the algorithm converged (for iterative methods). n_iterations : int Number of iterations used (for iterative methods). gap : float Optimality gap (upper_bound - lower_bound) for relaxation methods. """ assignments: NDArray[np.intp] cost: float converged: bool n_iterations: int gap: float
[docs] def validate_cost_tensor(cost_tensor: NDArray[np.float64]) -> Tuple[int, ...]: """ Validate cost tensor and return dimensions. Parameters ---------- cost_tensor : ndarray Cost tensor of arbitrary dimension. Returns ------- dims : tuple Dimensions of the cost tensor. Raises ------ ValueError If tensor has fewer than 2 dimensions. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> cost = np.random.rand(3, 4, 5) >>> dims = validate_cost_tensor(cost) >>> dims (3, 4, 5) >>> # 1D tensor should raise error >>> try: ... validate_cost_tensor(np.array([1, 2, 3])) ... except ValueError: ... print("Caught expected error") Caught expected error """ if cost_tensor.ndim < 2: raise ValueError( f"Cost tensor must have at least 2 dimensions, got {cost_tensor.ndim}" ) return cost_tensor.shape
[docs] def greedy_assignment_nd( cost_tensor: NDArray[np.float64], max_assignments: Optional[int] = None, ) -> AssignmentNDResult: """ Greedy solver for N-dimensional assignment. Selects minimum-cost tuples in order until no more valid assignments exist (no dimension index is repeated). Parameters ---------- cost_tensor : ndarray Cost tensor of shape (n1, n2, ..., nk). max_assignments : int, optional Maximum number of assignments to find (default: min(dimensions)). Returns ------- AssignmentNDResult Assignments, total cost, and algorithm info. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # 3D cost tensor: 3 measurements x 2 tracks x 2 hypotheses >>> cost = np.array([ ... [[1.0, 5.0], [3.0, 2.0]], # meas 0 ... [[4.0, 1.0], [2.0, 6.0]], # meas 1 ... [[2.0, 3.0], [5.0, 1.0]], # meas 2 ... ]) >>> result = greedy_assignment_nd(cost) >>> result.cost # Total cost of greedy solution 2.0 >>> len(result.assignments) # Number of assignments made 2 Notes ----- Greedy assignment is fast O(n log n) but not optimal. Used as heuristic or starting solution for optimization methods. """ dims = cost_tensor.shape n_dims = len(dims) if max_assignments is None: max_assignments = min(dims) # Flatten tensor with index mapping flat_costs = cost_tensor.ravel() sorted_indices = np.argsort(flat_costs) assignments: list[tuple[int, ...]] = [] used_indices: list[set[int]] = [set() for _ in range(n_dims)] for flat_idx in sorted_indices: if len(assignments) >= max_assignments: break # Convert flat index to multi-dimensional index multi_idx = np.unravel_index(flat_idx, dims) # Check if any dimension index is already used conflict = False for d, idx in enumerate(multi_idx): if idx in used_indices[d]: conflict = True break if not conflict: assignments.append(multi_idx) for d, idx in enumerate(multi_idx): used_indices[d].add(idx) assignments_array = np.array(assignments, dtype=np.intp) if assignments_array.size > 0: total_cost = float(np.sum(cost_tensor[tuple(assignments_array.T)])) else: total_cost = 0.0 return AssignmentNDResult( assignments=assignments_array, cost=total_cost, converged=True, n_iterations=1, gap=0.0, # Greedy doesn't compute lower bound )
def _recover_feasible_nd( cost_tensor: NDArray[np.float64], rows: NDArray[np.intp], cols: NDArray[np.intp], ) -> Tuple[NDArray[np.intp], float]: """Build a feasible N-D assignment from a fixed set of (dim0, dim1) pairs. The relaxed solution satisfies the first two dimensions' constraints but may reuse indices in the relaxed dimensions. Each remaining dimension is assigned by an exact 2-D assignment over the fixed pairs, which guarantees feasibility and therefore a valid upper bound. Parameters ---------- cost_tensor : ndarray Original cost tensor. rows, cols : ndarray Indices selected in the first two dimensions. Returns ------- assignments : ndarray Feasible assignment tuples, shape (n_assignments, n_dims). cost : float Total cost of the recovered assignment. """ dims = cost_tensor.shape n_dims = len(dims) n_assign = len(rows) # Partial tuples: start from the fixed (dim0, dim1) pairs. partial = [[int(rows[t]), int(cols[t])] for t in range(n_assign)] for d in range(2, n_dims): # Cost of extending each partial tuple with each index of dimension d, # minimized over the not-yet-assigned dimensions. block = np.empty((n_assign, dims[d])) for t in range(n_assign): sub = cost_tensor[tuple(partial[t])] # sub has axes (dims[d], dims[d+1], ...); minimize the trailing ones block[t] = sub.reshape(dims[d], -1).min(axis=1) r_idx, c_idx = linear_sum_assignment(block) chosen = {int(r): int(c) for r, c in zip(r_idx, c_idx)} for t in range(n_assign): # Dimension d may be smaller than the number of tuples; unmatched # tuples keep the greedy best index (feasibility is enforced only # among the matched ones, mirroring rectangular 2-D assignment). partial[t].append(chosen.get(t, int(np.argmin(block[t])))) assignments = np.array(partial, dtype=np.intp) if len(assignments) == 0: return np.empty((0, n_dims), dtype=np.intp), 0.0 cost = float(np.sum(cost_tensor[tuple(assignments.T)])) return assignments, cost
[docs] def relaxation_assignment_nd( cost_tensor: NDArray[np.float64], max_iterations: int = 100, tolerance: float = 1e-6, verbose: bool = False, ) -> AssignmentNDResult: """ Lagrangian relaxation solver for N-dimensional assignment. Relaxes the constraints on dimensions 3..N and solves the resulting two-dimensional problem exactly, which yields a valid lower bound on the optimal cost. Subgradient ascent on the multipliers tightens the bound; a feasible solution is recovered at each iteration to provide an upper bound. Parameters ---------- cost_tensor : ndarray Cost tensor of shape (n1, n2, ..., nk). max_iterations : int, optional Maximum iterations (default 100). tolerance : float, optional Convergence tolerance for the optimality gap (default 1e-6). verbose : bool, optional Print iteration info (default False). Returns ------- AssignmentNDResult Assignments, total cost, convergence info, and optimality gap. ``gap`` is ``best_upper_bound - best_lower_bound``; when ``converged`` is True the returned assignment is provably within ``tolerance`` of optimal. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # 3x3x3 assignment problem >>> rng = np.random.default_rng(42) >>> cost = rng.random((3, 3, 3)) >>> result = relaxation_assignment_nd(cost, max_iterations=50) >>> bool(result.gap >= -1e-9) # gap is a genuine bound True >>> result.assignments.shape[1] # 3D assignments 3 Notes ----- The relaxation follows Poore's formulation (see the module references): 1. Relax the constraints on dimensions 3..N with multipliers ``lambda``. 2. The inner problem separates: minimizing over the relaxed dimensions for each (i, j) pair leaves a 2-D assignment problem, solved **exactly**. Solving it exactly is what makes ``L(lambda)`` a valid lower bound -- a greedy inner solve does not bound the optimum and can certify optimality for suboptimal answers. 3. Recover a feasible solution (upper bound) by assigning each relaxed dimension with an exact 2-D assignment. 4. Ascend the multipliers along the constraint-violation subgradient. The reported ``gap`` uses the best bounds seen across all iterations, so it is a genuine optimality certificate rather than a heuristic score. """ dims = validate_cost_tensor(cost_tensor) n_dims = len(dims) # A 2-D problem needs no relaxation: solve it exactly. if n_dims == 2: rows, cols = linear_sum_assignment(cost_tensor) assignments = np.column_stack([rows, cols]).astype(np.intp) cost = float(cost_tensor[rows, cols].sum()) return AssignmentNDResult( assignments=assignments, cost=cost, converged=True, n_iterations=1, gap=0.0, ) free_dims = list(range(2, n_dims)) lambdas = [np.zeros(dims[d]) for d in free_dims] free_shape = tuple(dims[d] for d in free_dims) best_upper = np.inf best_lower = -np.inf best_assignments: Optional[NDArray[np.intp]] = None iteration = 0 for iteration in range(max_iterations): # Relaxed costs: c - sum of multipliers over the relaxed dimensions. relaxed = cost_tensor.copy() for k, d in enumerate(free_dims): shape = [1] * n_dims shape[d] = dims[d] relaxed = relaxed - lambdas[k].reshape(shape) # Minimize over the relaxed dimensions, leaving a 2-D problem. collapsed = relaxed.reshape(dims[0], dims[1], -1) reduced = collapsed.min(axis=2) best_free = collapsed.argmin(axis=2) # Exact 2-D solve => valid lower bound. rows, cols = linear_sum_assignment(reduced) lower = float(reduced[rows, cols].sum()) + float( sum(lam.sum() for lam in lambdas) ) best_lower = max(best_lower, lower) # Feasible recovery => valid upper bound. assignments, upper = _recover_feasible_nd(cost_tensor, rows, cols) if upper < best_upper: best_upper = upper best_assignments = assignments gap = best_upper - best_lower if verbose: print( f"Iter {iteration + 1}: LB={best_lower:.4f}, UB={best_upper:.4f}, " f"Gap={gap:.6f}" ) if gap < tolerance: if verbose: print(f"Converged at iteration {iteration + 1}") break # Subgradient: how often each relaxed index is used, minus one. chosen = np.array(np.unravel_index(best_free[rows, cols], free_shape)).reshape( len(free_dims), -1 ) subgradient = [] for k, d in enumerate(free_dims): counts = np.bincount(chosen[k], minlength=dims[d]).astype(float) subgradient.append(1.0 - counts) norm_sq = float(sum(float(np.sum(g**2)) for g in subgradient)) if norm_sq <= 0.0: # No constraint violated: the relaxed solution is feasible and # therefore optimal. break # Polyak step toward the current best upper bound. step = (best_upper - lower) / norm_sq if step <= 0.0: step = 1.0 / (iteration + 1) for k in range(len(free_dims)): lambdas[k] = lambdas[k] + step * subgradient[k] if best_assignments is None: best_assignments = np.empty((0, n_dims), dtype=np.intp) best_upper = 0.0 gap = best_upper - best_lower return AssignmentNDResult( assignments=best_assignments, cost=best_upper, converged=bool(gap < tolerance), n_iterations=iteration + 1, gap=gap, )
[docs] def auction_assignment_nd( cost_tensor: NDArray[np.float64], max_iterations: int = 100, epsilon: float = 0.01, verbose: bool = False, ) -> AssignmentNDResult: """ Auction algorithm for N-dimensional assignment. Inspired by the classical auction algorithm for 2D assignment, adapted to higher dimensions. Objects bid for assignments based on relative costs. Parameters ---------- cost_tensor : ndarray Cost tensor of shape (n1, n2, ..., nk). max_iterations : int, optional Maximum iterations (default 100). epsilon : float, optional Bid increment (default 0.01). Larger epsilon → fewer iterations, worse solution; smaller epsilon → more iterations, better solution. verbose : bool, optional Print iteration info (default False). Returns ------- AssignmentNDResult Assignments, total cost, convergence info, gap estimate. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # 4D assignment: sensors x measurements x tracks x hypotheses >>> np.random.seed(123) >>> cost = np.random.rand(2, 3, 3, 2) * 10 >>> result = auction_assignment_nd(cost, max_iterations=50, epsilon=0.1) >>> len(result.assignments) > 0 True >>> result.n_iterations <= 50 True Notes ----- The algorithm maintains a "price" for each index and allows bidding (price adjustment) to maximize value. Converges to epsilon-optimal solution in finite iterations. """ dims = cost_tensor.shape n_dims = len(dims) # Initialize prices (one per dimension per index) prices = [np.zeros(dim) for dim in dims] # Track the best feasible assignment (by actual cost) over all iterations. # Iteration 0 has zero prices, so the plain greedy solution is included. best_cost = np.inf best_assignments = np.empty((0, n_dims), dtype=np.intp) for iteration in range(max_iterations): # Compute profit: cost - price penalty profit = cost_tensor.copy() for d in range(n_dims): shape = [1] * n_dims shape[d] = dims[d] profit = profit - prices[d].reshape(shape) # Find best assignment at current prices (greedy) result = greedy_assignment_nd(profit) if len(result.assignments) == 0: break # Evaluate at actual costs and keep the best solution found actual_cost = float(np.sum(cost_tensor[tuple(result.assignments.T)])) if actual_cost < best_cost or ( actual_cost == best_cost and len(result.assignments) > len(best_assignments) ): best_cost = actual_cost best_assignments = result.assignments # Update prices: increase price for "in-demand" indices demands = [np.zeros(dim) for dim in dims] for assignment in result.assignments: for d, idx in enumerate(assignment): demands[d][idx] += 1 for d in range(n_dims): prices[d] += epsilon * (demands[d] - 1.0) if verbose and (iteration + 1) % 10 == 0: print(f"Iter {iteration + 1}: Cost={actual_cost:.4f}") if not np.isfinite(best_cost): best_cost = 0.0 return AssignmentNDResult( assignments=best_assignments, cost=best_cost, converged=True, n_iterations=iteration + 1, gap=0.0, # Auction algorithm doesn't track gap formally )
[docs] def detect_dimension_conflicts( assignments: NDArray[np.intp], dims: Tuple[int, ...], ) -> bool: """ Check if assignments violate dimension uniqueness. For valid assignment, each index should appear at most once per dimension. Parameters ---------- assignments : ndarray Array of shape (n_assignments, n_dimensions) with assignments. dims : tuple Dimensions of the cost tensor. Returns ------- has_conflicts : bool True if any index appears more than once in any dimension. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # Valid assignment: no index repeated in any dimension >>> assignments = np.array([[0, 0], [1, 1]]) >>> detect_dimension_conflicts(assignments, (3, 3)) False >>> # Invalid: index 0 used twice in first dimension >>> assignments = np.array([[0, 0], [0, 1]]) >>> detect_dimension_conflicts(assignments, (3, 3)) True """ n_dims = len(dims) for d in range(n_dims): indices_in_dim = assignments[:, d] if len(indices_in_dim) != len(np.unique(indices_in_dim)): return True return False
[docs] class SparseCostTensor: """ Sparse representation of N-dimensional cost tensor. For assignment problems where most entries represent invalid assignments (infinite cost), storing only valid entries reduces memory by 50% or more and speeds up greedy algorithms. Attributes ---------- dims : tuple Shape of the full tensor (n1, n2, ..., nk). indices : ndarray Array of shape (n_valid, n_dims) with valid entry indices. costs : ndarray Array of shape (n_valid,) with costs for valid entries. default_cost : float Cost for entries not explicitly stored (default: inf). Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # Create sparse tensor for 10x10x10 problem with 50 valid entries >>> dims = (10, 10, 10) >>> valid_indices = np.random.randint(0, 10, size=(50, 3)) >>> valid_costs = np.random.rand(50) >>> sparse = SparseCostTensor(dims, valid_indices, valid_costs) >>> sparse.n_valid 50 >>> sparse.sparsity # Fraction of valid entries 0.05 >>> # Convert from dense tensor with inf for invalid >>> dense = np.full((5, 5, 5), np.inf) >>> dense[0, 0, 0] = 1.0 >>> dense[1, 1, 1] = 2.0 >>> sparse = SparseCostTensor.from_dense(dense) >>> sparse.n_valid 2 """
[docs] def __init__( self, dims: Tuple[int, ...], indices: NDArray[np.intp], costs: NDArray[np.float64], default_cost: float = np.inf, ): """ Initialize sparse cost tensor. Parameters ---------- dims : tuple Shape of the full tensor. indices : ndarray Valid entry indices, shape (n_valid, n_dims). costs : ndarray Costs for valid entries, shape (n_valid,). default_cost : float Cost for invalid (unstored) entries. """ self.dims = dims self.indices = np.asarray(indices, dtype=np.intp) self.costs = np.asarray(costs, dtype=np.float64) self.default_cost = default_cost # Build lookup for O(1) cost retrieval self._cost_map: dict[Tuple[int, ...], float] = {} for i in range(len(self.costs)): key = tuple(self.indices[i]) self._cost_map[key] = self.costs[i]
@property def n_dims(self) -> int: """Number of dimensions.""" return len(self.dims) @property def n_valid(self) -> int: """Number of valid (finite cost) entries.""" return len(self.costs) @property def sparsity(self) -> float: """Fraction of tensor that is valid (0 to 1).""" total_size = int(np.prod(self.dims)) return self.n_valid / total_size if total_size > 0 else 0.0 @property def memory_savings(self) -> float: """Estimated memory savings vs dense representation (0 to 1).""" dense_size = np.prod(self.dims) * 8 # 8 bytes per float64 sparse_size = self.n_valid * (8 + self.n_dims * 8) # cost + indices return max(0, 1 - sparse_size / dense_size) if dense_size > 0 else 0.0
[docs] def get_cost(self, index: Tuple[int, ...]) -> float: """Get cost for a specific index tuple.""" return self._cost_map.get(index, self.default_cost)
[docs] def to_dense(self) -> NDArray[np.float64]: """ Convert to dense tensor representation. Returns ------- dense : ndarray Full tensor with default_cost for unstored entries. Notes ----- May use significant memory for large tensors. """ dense = np.full(self.dims, self.default_cost, dtype=np.float64) for i in range(len(self.costs)): dense[tuple(self.indices[i])] = self.costs[i] return dense
[docs] @classmethod def from_dense( cls, dense: NDArray[np.float64], threshold: float = 1e10, ) -> "SparseCostTensor": """ Create sparse tensor from dense array. Parameters ---------- dense : ndarray Dense cost tensor. threshold : float Entries above this value are considered invalid. Default 1e10 (catches np.inf and large values). Returns ------- SparseCostTensor Sparse representation. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> dense = np.array([[[1, np.inf], [np.inf, 2]], ... [[np.inf, 3], [4, np.inf]]]) >>> sparse = SparseCostTensor.from_dense(dense) >>> sparse.n_valid 4 """ valid_mask = dense < threshold indices = np.array(np.where(valid_mask)).T costs = dense[valid_mask] return cls(dense.shape, indices, costs, default_cost=np.inf)
[docs] def greedy_assignment_nd_sparse( sparse_cost: SparseCostTensor, max_assignments: Optional[int] = None, ) -> AssignmentNDResult: """ Greedy solver for sparse N-dimensional assignment. Selects minimum-cost tuples from valid entries only, which is much faster than dense greedy when sparsity < 0.5. Parameters ---------- sparse_cost : SparseCostTensor Sparse cost tensor with valid entries only. max_assignments : int, optional Maximum number of assignments (default: min(dimensions)). Returns ------- AssignmentNDResult Assignments, total cost, and algorithm info. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # Create sparse problem >>> dims = (10, 10, 10) >>> # Only 20 valid assignments out of 1000 >>> indices = np.array([[i, i, i] for i in range(10)] + ... [[i, (i+1)%10, (i+2)%10] for i in range(10)]) >>> costs = np.random.rand(20) >>> sparse = SparseCostTensor(dims, indices, costs) >>> result = greedy_assignment_nd_sparse(sparse) >>> result.converged True Notes ----- Time complexity is O(n_valid * log(n_valid)) vs O(total_size * log(total_size)) for dense greedy. For a 10x10x10 tensor with 50 valid entries, this is 50*log(50) vs 1000*log(1000), about 20x faster. """ dims = sparse_cost.dims n_dims = sparse_cost.n_dims if max_assignments is None: max_assignments = min(dims) # Sort valid entries by cost sorted_indices = np.argsort(sparse_cost.costs) assignments: List[Tuple[int, ...]] = [] used_indices: List[set[int]] = [set() for _ in range(n_dims)] total_cost = 0.0 for sorted_idx in sorted_indices: if len(assignments) >= max_assignments: break multi_idx = tuple(sparse_cost.indices[sorted_idx]) # Check if any dimension index is already used conflict = False for d, idx in enumerate(multi_idx): if idx in used_indices[d]: conflict = True break if not conflict: assignments.append(multi_idx) total_cost += sparse_cost.costs[sorted_idx] for d, idx in enumerate(multi_idx): used_indices[d].add(idx) assignments_array = np.array(assignments, dtype=np.intp) if assignments_array.size == 0: assignments_array = np.empty((0, n_dims), dtype=np.intp) return AssignmentNDResult( assignments=assignments_array, cost=total_cost, converged=True, n_iterations=1, gap=0.0, )
[docs] def assignment_nd( cost: Union[NDArray[np.float64], SparseCostTensor], method: str = "auto", max_assignments: Optional[int] = None, max_iterations: int = 100, tolerance: float = 1e-6, epsilon: float = 0.01, verbose: bool = False, ) -> AssignmentNDResult: """ Unified interface for N-dimensional assignment. Automatically selects between dense and sparse algorithms based on input type and sparsity. Parameters ---------- cost : ndarray or SparseCostTensor Cost tensor (dense) or sparse cost representation. method : str Algorithm to use: 'auto', 'greedy', 'relaxation', 'auction'. 'auto' selects greedy for sparse, relaxation for dense. max_assignments : int, optional Maximum number of assignments for greedy methods. max_iterations : int Maximum iterations for iterative methods. tolerance : float Convergence tolerance for relaxation. epsilon : float Price increment for auction algorithm. verbose : bool Print progress information. Returns ------- AssignmentNDResult Assignment solution. Examples -------- >>> import numpy as np >>> # Dense usage >>> cost = np.random.rand(4, 4, 4) >>> result = assignment_nd(cost, method='greedy') >>> result.converged True >>> # Sparse usage (more efficient for large sparse problems) >>> dense = np.full((20, 20, 20), np.inf) >>> for i in range(20): ... dense[i, i, i] = np.random.rand() >>> sparse = SparseCostTensor.from_dense(dense) >>> result = assignment_nd(sparse, method='auto') >>> result.converged True See Also -------- greedy_assignment_nd : Dense greedy algorithm. greedy_assignment_nd_sparse : Sparse greedy algorithm. relaxation_assignment_nd : Lagrangian relaxation. auction_assignment_nd : Auction algorithm. """ if isinstance(cost, SparseCostTensor): # Sparse input - use sparse algorithm if method in ("auto", "greedy"): return greedy_assignment_nd_sparse(cost, max_assignments) else: # Convert to dense for other methods dense = cost.to_dense() if method == "relaxation": return relaxation_assignment_nd( dense, max_iterations, tolerance, verbose ) elif method == "auction": return auction_assignment_nd( dense, max_iterations, epsilon=epsilon, verbose=verbose ) else: raise ValueError(f"Unknown method: {method}") else: # Dense input cost = np.asarray(cost, dtype=np.float64) if method == "auto": # Use relaxation for better solutions on dense return relaxation_assignment_nd(cost, max_iterations, tolerance, verbose) elif method == "greedy": return greedy_assignment_nd(cost, max_assignments) elif method == "relaxation": return relaxation_assignment_nd(cost, max_iterations, tolerance, verbose) elif method == "auction": return auction_assignment_nd( cost, max_iterations, epsilon=epsilon, verbose=verbose ) else: raise ValueError(f"Unknown method: {method}")
__all__ = [ "AssignmentNDResult", "SparseCostTensor", "validate_cost_tensor", "greedy_assignment_nd", "greedy_assignment_nd_sparse", "relaxation_assignment_nd", "auction_assignment_nd", "detect_dimension_conflicts", "assignment_nd", ]